Lumpy Skin Disease returns as social, infrastructural factors dampen Uttarakhand’s vaccination drive

The issue of information not reaching marginalised communities, lack of roads in difficult terrains and official apathy during last year’s drive lead to a second wave of the viral infection  Almora, Uttarakhand: "One of my cows has not stood up for the last 24 days. When the first one got sick, we could not separate it due to lack of space. Now both are sick, and we have no milk to consume. We are forced to buy powdered milk for my four-year-old grandson," says Kaushaliya Devi, a Dalit farmer from Dhudholi village in Almora. Kaushaliya’s cows are among the thousands infected with Lumpy Skin Disease (LSD) in the second wave of the viral infection to hit the state since last year. In a reply to a question in the Lok Sabha on February 7, Union Minister for Fisheries, Animal Husbandry and Dairying Parshottam Rupala said 921 cattle died in the state till then and 6,96,811 cattle received vaccine against the disease.Caused by Lumpy Skin Disease Virus (LSDV), the condition is characterised by fever, skin nodules, enlarged lymph nodes, skin oedema, and sometimes death. It can cause a temporary reduction in milk production, temporary or permanent sterility in bulls and damage to hides. The World Organisation for Animal Health categorises the LSD as a notifiable disease, which means it must be reported to an appropriate authority if suspected or confirmed."There are many animals that cannot get up and many that cannot sit down for days because their feet are swollen.... others have swollen udders or briskets. Some will develop nodules, while others will not," Dr Surbhi*, a government veterinary doctor in Champawat district, tells 101Reporters.The LSD has no antiviral treatment yet, so supportive care, which includes antibiotics and painkillers, is only possible. However, the cost of treatment has been burning holes in the pockets of dairy farmers. "When cows are ill, milk production drops. We dairy farmers have spent twice as much on treatment as we make from milk sales. We are completely dependent on farming and dairying, so it has been difficult,” says Bhuvan Purohit from Dhudholi.Purohit claims he did not even make enough money this year to buy feed for his cows. “We have had a rough time for the last couple of months. I have spent Rs 25,000 on my cows so far. Medicines are very expensive, and minerals and other supplements should also be given."  Accessibility an issueThe Central government’s action plan has mentioned a vaccination target of 9,10,000 out of the total 18,52,123 cattle in Uttarakhand. According to Uttarakhand Livestock Development Board, 2,92,748 cattle have been vaccinated so far. While the action plan to control the spread and severity of the disease involves vaccination push, many villagers in Almora have claimed that lack of accessibility prevented them from benefitting from such drives."So far, a calf and cow of mine have died. Last time, the vaccination drives were held near places connected by roads. But my home is quite far away. I was aware that a vaccination drive would take place, but had no information on the dates," says Mohan Singh Adhikari, a dairy farmer in Dhudholi. The pradhan (village chief) coordinated the drive through a WhatsApp group. However, since all farmers, especially those from marginalised communities, may not have access to smartphones, the project did not succeed fully. Due to the presence of so many unvaccinated cattle, the risk of a fresh bout of infection was always there.Kaushaliya Devi's cow affected by LSD could not stand up for 24 days (Photo - Swati Thapa, 101Reporters)With new cases surfacing since March this year, the state animal husbandry department launched a doorstep vaccination drive using animal ambulances. On getting a request from helpline number 1962, a medical team would visit the village to vaccinate the animals. However, Purohit claims many families, including his one, could not make use of the facility due to a lack of road connectivity.     "No one came to our village. We contacted the authorities, but they said they were understaffed. This is a large area. As many as 116 villages constitute the development block of Dwarahat, but there were not enough people to serve everyone," he adds. In several villages, the Dalit hamlets are located far away from the village epicentre, due to which information also escapes them. To this effect, Dalit dairy farmer Prema Devi mentions how she never got to know about the vaccination drive as her house is in the village outskirts."The ambulance service came once when I called them. But the second time, the staff concerned told me that they would come tomorrow as it was raining then. But they have not reached out so far," says Adhikari.In many families, male members migrate for work. Hence, the burden of duties weighs heavily on women. As such, in Uttarakhand, women are mostly the caretakers of cattle. During last year’s drive, many could not get their animals vaccinated due to daily domestic chores. They mostly do not have access to smartphones either.  Under-reporting of deaths"A majority of bovines have not been vaccinated. The number is huge and we did ask them [the animal husbandry department] to provide preventive vaccination to the healthy ones right now. However, the doctor said it will be done after the cases and spread came down. I do not know when that will be. I feel vaccination will not happen," says Adhikari. The LSD deaths have also been under-reported due to lack of a proper documentation system. "We are not told to follow any procedure to report cattle death. So, all we do is bury them in the soil. There is no reporting of any kind. At least 15 cattle deaths would have taken place in this village alone, so definitely the death toll would be much higher in Almora district," he avers. An email sent to the animal husbandry department on whether they have raised awareness on how to deal with animal deaths did not elicit a reply. Many farmers are hesitant to mention the actual cause of death, fearing they would not receive the insurance money. The state government is not providing any separate compensation for LSD deaths, but it is covered under its Livestock Insurance Scheme. Yet, farmers are not keen on applying as red tape deters them. Moreover, a postmortem report from a doctor is required for applying.  *Name changed to protect identityEdited by Rekha PulinnoliCover photo - Lumpy Skin Disease is characterised by fever, skin nodules, enlarged lymph nodes, skin oedema, and sometimes death (Photo - Swati Thapa, 101Reporters)

Vocal for local: Seed bank in Uttarakhand rescues indigenous crops, engages women farmers

A group of 450 farmers, mostly women, nourishes the bank with traditional varieties of millets and grains in Almora districtAlmora, Uttarakhand: “There is a lot of work at home, and we have a daughter. So we cannot leave together. My husband goes for the training and shares the details when he returns,” says Bhavana Purohit, a farmer from Dunagiri in Almora district of Uttarakhand. Organised by Geeta Bisht in her position as a team member of Chaukhutia-based Institute of Himalayan Environmental Research and Education (INHERE), the training that Bhavana mentions revolves around conserving the best indigenous seeds through organic farming. A Naugaon resident hailing from a family of farmers, Geeta also conducts workshops and field trips for farmers every 15 days.However, one thing that she noticed was that women missed all the sessions. "Bringing them to the forefront was a challenging task. Women never seem to have time. If you visit them during the day, it is either time to go to the jungle, pick children from school or tend to their cattle,” says Geeta, whose persistent efforts have helped form a group of 450 farmers that nurtures a seed bank, of which only around 50 are men.Women are the true farmers of Uttarakhand, but agricultural data belie their status as farmers as they work in the fields owned by their husbands or fathers. According to Agriculture Census 2015-16, women hold 11.72% of the total operated area in the country and engage in agricultural activities in these lands. Women farmers formed only 7.3% of the beneficiaries under the Pradhan Mantri Fasal Bima Yojana in 2020-21. As for PM-Kisan Samman Nidhi for the same period, they were positioned at 17.7%. Despite the drawbacks, Geeta knew from the very beginning the role to be played by women in making the INHERE seed bank initiative a success. As farm work was viewed as an extension of a woman's domestic responsibilities, she was the primary decision maker on the type of crop to be grown.However, as their lives revolved around their families, Geeta had to visit them on Sundays or national holidays, when their children did not have to go to school, to enlist their support for the initiative.While women were often the primary decision-makers on the type of crop to be grown, they were often too busy with domestic and field work and couldn't be easily convinced to join training and knowledge-transfer programmes (Photos - Swati Thapa, 101Reporters) Back in the fieldsA vast majority of the people in rural Uttarakhand cultivate one or more crops. However, a shift from indigenous varieties to high-yielding genetically modified crops has triggered the use of urea and chemical pesticides in recent years. A study published in the International Journal of Applied Sciences and Biotechnology suggests that inordinate application of urea can effect changes in soil macrofauna. Its continuous and excessive use may also alter soil pH, microbial population and biochemical parameters. All these factors have resulted in less production of local varieties in Uttarakhand, with some on the verge of extinction. In 2018, Geeta developed a system wherein farmers cultivated the near-extinct local varieties and deposited the seeds coming out of their fields in the seed bank operating in the INHERE’s Chaukhutia office, so that all of them had equal access to indigenous seeds. "Open-pollinated seeds (they will produce plants genetically similar to the parent plant) are not easily available to farmers. Our initiative aims at ensuring access to such seeds," explains INHERE secretary Chinmaya Sah.Seeds are procured as per the market rate. For example, the market pricing of one kg radish seeds from Dunagiri region is Rs 2,000. After procuring for this amount, the seeds are cleaned, packaged and sold locally at the seed bank for Rs 2,500. This discounted price (the same seeds in the market would be priced at Rs 3,000) has attracted more farmers to the bank to either buy or barter, in case they possess seeds that the bank does not have.Moreover, the programme has brought farmers closer through a WhatsApp group and telephonic conversations. Geeta has also helped Bhuvan and Bhavana Purohit to open a branch of the seed bank at their home in Dunagiri.“Earlier, if we wanted indigenous seeds, we had to go to places like Ramnagar, located 107 km away. Even Himachali garlic had replaced our native variety. I realised the importance of traditional crops after I got in touch with Geeta ji. I learnt a lot from her and the farmers’ meets that I attended. We are no longer reliant on market seeds; we have our own seeds of garlic, spinach and millet,” beams Bhuvan.According to Geeta, the INHERE bank presently has 23 seed varieties. “We mainly focus on madua (finger millet), Jhangora (barnyard), kauni (foxtail) and cheeda and more red-coloured millets. To convince farmers, I always remind them how consuming regional varieties would keep them healthy,” she says.However, it took at least one year to convince women to join her training programmes, where she educated them on the farming practices that promised more yield using less seeds.  Nandan Singh Bisht, a farmer from Dunagiri, remembers how local varieties of alsi, bhangira (hemp seeds), Jhangora and kauni were almost wiped out from their farms before they made a comeback through the seed bank initiative. “We have these crops again with us."The seed bank in Chaukhutia presently has 23 seed varieties including various types of indigenous millets and vegetables (Photos - Swati Thapa, 101Reporters)Many of the indigenous varieties that were brought back were millets, as they are the staple foods of the hills. At the same time, indigenous varieties of spinach, onion, garlic, gourd and pumpkin were among the vegetables that were saved from gradual extinction.To tap the market potential of organic millets, considered as superfoods in urban markets, INHERE also set up a farmer producer company in Chaukutia. The certified organic products from Uttarakhand’s villages now reach every corner of the country through e-commerce platform Amazon.“We want to create a system by which we could evaluate the yield in the hills during the harvest season every year and provide the farmers’ households with a decent incentive. This will encourage people to grow more,” Sah says.  Agent of changeWith women's low social mobility, gaining the support of men in their families has always been a major challenge. Initially, many were unhappy about their wives attending the INHERE’s training session. They even created problems at home for participating in the meetings.Geeta agrees that there were several instances when upset and drunk men questioned her intentions. “However, when they realised the potential of this initiative, they could no longer question me. Anyone can lecture, but when one gets down to fieldwork, one realises the problems. Patriarchy is definitely one of them," she says. (Above) Kaushaliya Devi, a farmer from Chinoni notes how when women work in their fields, they tackle labour-intensive work collectively. "Tilling the soil is hard, so village women help each other. If someone has oxen, we take their help" (Photos - Swati Thapa, 101Reporters)“We do not ask men for help because we know they will never do it,” Kaushaliya Devi, a farmer from Chinoni, sums up the problem in one sentence. Devi is in the field before 6 am and returns only by 11 am. After that comes the household responsibilities. “The body becomes so exhausted that at the end of the day, we have no idea where we are sleeping,” she laments.The condition of women farm labourers is also pathetic. "I get Rs 250 to 300 per day. However, men manage to get around Rs 500. We do similar work, the only difference being that women cannot lift much weight as they do," says Basanti Devi from Hat village.When women work in their fields, they tackle labour-intensive work collectively. "Tilling the soil is hard, so village women help each other. If someone has oxen, we take their help. Otherwise, we do it collectively," Kaushaliya explains.Though women collectively hire tractors and threshers to get the farm work done, illiteracy and lack of technical know-how pose hurdles before them. “We have to depend on men to operate these machines and to get the meter reading, based on which the machine rental per hour is decided,” says Basanti.Through the seed bank initiative, women are banding together to save what is vital for their livelihoods. However, facilitators like Geeta still have a long way to go. The fact that Bhavana is yet to attend a single training session proves it clearly. Cover photo - The seed bank at INHERE (Photo - Swati Thapa, 101Reporters)Edited Rekha Pulinnoli